domingo, agosto 09, 2015

From GM Watch: GMO safety assessments have important knowledge gaps – scientific report

Report commissioned by the Norwegian Environment Agency concludes that Intacta Roundup Ready 2 Pro soybeans have not been proven safe and that studies raise safety concerns

Ever wondered why there is such a massive gap between your view of GMO safety and the view of most governments and pro-GMO scientists? Ever asked yourself whether, in doubting GMO safety, your perception may be skewed or that you may be guilty of championing dodgy science or ignoring “sound” science?

If your answer to either of these questions is yes, a new scientific report commissioned by the Norwegian Environment Agency will reassure you that it is the GMO proponents’ views that are skewed, not your own.

The report investigates whether the GM soybean Intacta Roundup Ready 2 Pro grown in Brazil is safe for health and the environment, as well as sustainable. This GM variety is also authorized in Argentina, Paraguay and Uruguay, and may be present in Bolivia due to illegal introductions from the neighbouring countries.

The report, by Georgina Catacora-­Vargas of GenØk Centre for Biosafety, concludes that:
* In the scientific literature there are important gaps of knowledge about the safety of GM crops and a lack of proof of their safety.
* Authorizations of GM crops are given on the basis of incomplete information and research (provided by the companies that develop them) with significant methodological weaknesses.
* There is only limited research on stacked GM crops such as Intacta RR2 Pro, including on the combined effects of the insect resistant and herbicide tolerant genes.

Catacora-­Vargas searched for animal feeding studies on Intacta RR2 Pro but found only a 42-day nutritional study in chickens and a medium-term 90-day feeding trial in mice. Neither is long enough to show long-term health effects.

Catacora-­Vargas cites the pig feeding study by Dr Judy Carman and colleagues as a potentially informative study, noting that adverse health effects were found in the GMO-fed pigs. Catacora-Vargas also mentions the 2-year Seralini study on GMO maize and Roundup as indicative that long-term studies are needed.

The author’s consideration of these findings is in stark contrast to the determination of the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) to ignore or dismiss worrying findings in independent animal feeding studies.

No GMOs are grown or sold in Norway due to the country’s Gene Technology Act, which requires that the GMO is shown to be “of benefit to society and… likely to promote sustainable development”. Thus far, no GMO has satisfied these conditions.

In conclusion, the stance of the new report and of the Norwegian government on GMOs is likely not so far apart from the views of many GMO skeptics.

The report is now available from the website of GenØk-Centre for Biosafety:
http://genok.com/arkiv/4185/

Etiquetas: , , , ,

miércoles, abril 02, 2014

Consideraciones socio-económicas en los procesos de toma de decisiones de los organismos genéticamente modificados, por Georgina Catacora


Este informe provee insumos generales sobre qué son, por qué, cuándo y cómo incluir las cuestiones socio-económicas en los procesos de bioseguridad de los OGMs -- un tema postergado por mucho tiempo y en actual debate en el marco del Protocolo de Cartagena y políticas nacionales de varios países.
Para acceder al documento completo (formato PDF) haga clic en el enlace a continuación y descargue el archivo:

Etiquetas: ,

viernes, septiembre 27, 2013

Yes it can be done: Food needs can be met with agroecological vision for agriculture and science

September 17, 2013

THIRD WORLD NETWORK INFORMATION SERVICE ON SUSTAINABLE AGRICULTURE 
Dear friends and colleagues, 
Re: Food needs can be met with agroecological vision for agriculture and science 
In the article below, the authors from Lancaster University and GenØk - Centre for Biosafety call for a new vision for agriculture and science; one where there is agricultural diversification and where agricultural research and development is reoriented towards diverse local conditions and needs, and towards farmers' knowledge. 
This is because the current industrial monoculture model of production, of both food and knowledge, does not meet global food needs. The result is physical and economic disconnection between production and consumption, as well as private control of the crucial knowledge base that shapes agriculture. The approach also assumes that science has a well-defined understanding of the technologies (including GM crops) needed to overcome such challenges, but neglects the extensive diversity of local conditions and knowledge systems, resulting in suppression of more effective sustainable alternatives. 
The alternative agroecological vision for agriculture and food supply is not just theory. The authors present examples of how local expertise and knowledge integrated with leading scientific research have demonstrated the capacity to increase yields sustainably, decrease polluting inputs, promote food security and improve livelihoods. 
With best wishes,
Third World Network
131 Jalan Macalister
10400 Penang
Malaysia

Farming and knowledge monocultures are misconceived 
Food needs can be met with a new vision for agriculture and science, say Brian Wynne and Georgina Catacora-Vargas. 

Etiquetas: , , ,

jueves, enero 24, 2013

Genetically Modified Organisms - A Summary of Potential Adverse Effects Relevant to Sustainable Development

http://www.genok.no/nyheter_cms/2012/januar/ny-biosikkerhetsrapport-genetically-modified-organisms-a-summary-of-potential-adverse-effects-relevant-to-sustainable-development/222

06.01.2012

Skrevet av Georgina Catacora-Vargas

GenØk Biosafety Report 2011/02
This report was commissioned from GenØk - Centre for Biosafety by Nordic Ecolabel. April 2011.
Summary
Genetically modified organisms (GMOs) are one of the most widespread and controversial products of modern biotechnology. The changes introduced in organisms and their secondary effects in complex natural and anthropogenic systems have raised a series of concerns and uncertainties with regard to their safety and the production packages that they rely on. These concerns are linked to the potential impacts of GMOs on the achievement of sustainable development.

This report emphasizes that the potential impacts of GMOs take place along their life cycle and value chain. In this sense, assessments only at specific stages (commonly at open field production or consumption) are incomplete, limiting the holistic understanding of impacts and their intertwined nature. This is consistent with findings in the literature review, carried out to identify potential effects along the value chain of GMOs, which show the potential multiple links and combinatorial effects of

GMOs at different stages (e.g., from their research and development (R&D) to commercialization). Another feature of this report is that it focuses on potential adverse effects of GMOs (particularly GM crops) that may impact sustainable development.

At the R&D level, intellectual property rights (IRP) on GMOs impact the objectives, market organization and regulation, among others, of the modern biotechnology industry. IPR on GMOs, mainly GM seeds, have economic and social effects as well. This applies especially to farmers in relation to legal and economic liabilities arising from the unintentional presence of GMOs. Impacts at the production stage, mainly of GM crops, are related to the inherent characteristics of the GMOs and to the production packages that they rely on. Imbalance and contamination (both genetic and chemical) of the (agro) ecosystems are the most commonly reported adverse impacts at the ecological level. Changes in land use and production costs, dependency on a specific technological package, weakening of food sovereignty, inequity in access to the technology and benefits sharing, occupational health risks, and tensions among adopter and non-adopters of GMOs are some of the economic and social potential implications of GMOs at the production stage. During harvesting, storage, conditioning and processing of GMOs, the changes in yield, the economic implications of contamination, the limited options for differentiation and segregation for small-scale producers and enterprises are the main possible adverse impacts. Since GM-crops production is inserted into the industrial agricultural sector, particularly for the production of commodities, the transportation and commercialization of GMOs are linked to high carbon generation and energy consumption, market concentration and vertical integration, which relates to limited opportunities for fair trade. As for consumption of GMOs, the main issues are related to potential harm to animals (farm or wild) and human health, including an ethical issue on the right of informed consumption.


All these concerns have set the need for international agreements and national legal frameworks to contribute to the safe transport, handling and use of GMOs in order to minimize or prevent adverse effects. In this regard, relevant international agreements dealing with GMOs are the Convention on Biological Diversity (CDB), the Cartagena Protocol on Biosafety (CPB), the newly agreed upon Nagoya-Kuala Lumpur Supplementary Protocol on Liability and Redress to the CPB, Codex Alimentarius, the International Plant Protection Convention (IPPC), standards, recommendations and guidelines of the World Organization for Animal Health (OIE), the WTO Agreement on the Application of Sanitary and Phytosanitary Measures (SPS Agreement) and the Aarhus Convention specifically related to the right to public participation in biosafety decision-making. At the regional level, the EU probably has the most developed biosafety regulation, which deals with the deliberate release of GMOs into the environment, GM food and feed, traceability and labelling, transboundary movements and co-existence, among others. At the national level, the Norwegian Gene Technology Act is the most prominent example, with the inclusion of sustainable development, societal utility and the ethical aspects of biosafety regulation.


In the global context of biosafety, labelling and traceability are important since this will:


i) provide means for monitoring long-term impacts on the environment and health, and
ii) facilitate informed decisions among users and consumers. Besides initiatives on GMO labelling, GM-free certification provided by organic farming, sustainable development initiatives and fair trade represent other approaches to addressing GMO labelling. In addition, the GMO-free regions movement also intends to create products and services with a differentiated identity by avoiding GMO production.

Etiquetas: , ,

domingo, enero 22, 2012

TRANSGENES EN EL MAÍZ MEXICANO, DIEZ AÑOS DESPUÉS DEL DESCUBRIMIENTO DE LA CONTAMINACIÓN GENÉTICA

(Tomado del Boletín RALLT #458)

David Quist y Georgina Catacora-Vargas

GenØk –Centro para la Bioseguridad–, Tromso, Noruega.

En esta semana hace 10 años, la revista científica Nature publicó el descubrimiento de genes transgénicos en variedades criollas de maíz en Oaxaca. Este hallazgo fue una alerta temprana sobre la propagación incontrolable de cultivos genéticamente modificados (GM) una vez introducidos en el medio ambiente.

Varios científicos han corroborado la dispersión de transgenes en variedades criollas de maíz en diferentes estados de México: Distrito Federal (2003), Guanajuato, Veracruz y Yucatán (2002) y, nuevamente, Oaxaca (2001 y 2004) .

Por tanto, la pregunta ya no es si los transgenes podrían contaminar la diversidad del maíz en México, sino qué podemos perder si esto continúa.

México es centro de origen y diversificación genética del maíz. Este patrimonio nacional es un recurso esencial para mejorar las variedades y su rendimiento, fortalecer su resistencia a enfermedades y responder a los desafíos que plantea el cambio climático. Además, es alimento básico en la dieta mexicana, por tanto, de gran importancia social, económica y cultural.

¿Qué sucede cuando variedades GM cruzan con variedades criollas? Se corre el riesgo de que la diversidad de maíz se reduzca. Sin embargo, el seguimiento experimental de ello aun no se ha realizado. La contaminación de variedades criollas por transgenes resulta en su transgenización, dando lugar a una serie de cuestiones ambientales y en salud aún sin resolver, ya que las preguntas adecuadas para su asesorameinto siguen sin abordaje adecuado.

¿Cuál es la probabilidad de que variedades GM crucen con variedades criollas y generen dichos riesgos? Depende de su proximidad. Desde 2005, mediante la Ley de Bioseguridad de Organismos Genéticamente Modificados (LBOGM), en México es posible aprobar solicitudes de introducción de maíz GM en áreas no catalogadas como protegidas (118 autorizaciones han sido otorgadas en el país en los últimos tres años ).

En un informe de 2009, la Comisión Nacional para el Conocimiento y Uso de la Biodiversidad (Conabio) indica que el área de distribución del maíz criollo abarca prácticamente todo México. Según la ubicación de variedades del grano GM aprobadas para pruebas experimentales se evidencia una sobreposición significativa entre las zonas de producción de maíz transgénico con el de variedades criollas, aumentando significativamente la probabilidad de dispersión de transgenes mediante cruza. Esto cuestiona la efectividad de delimitar las zonas consideradas centro de origen y diversidad genética del maíz en México, o si, en su caso, la totalidad del país debería recibir el estatus de área protegida con relación al mismo. La determinación de estos límites está en discusión, y ello tendrá amplios impactos sobre la futura introducción de maíz GM y en la conservación de variedades criollas.

Dada la estrecha relación entre biodiversidad y conocimiento local, los cambios en las variedades criollas de dicho grano también podrían alterar las prácticas de manejo de su cultivo, e impactar negativamente en las estrategias de vida y capacidad de las comunidades locales de alimentarse a sí mismas .

¿Cómo podrían incluirse de manera adecuada los aspectos ecológicos, sociales y económicos relacionados con la contaminación de variedades criollas? ¿E incluirlas en la toma de decisiones sobre maíz GM? Incorporando cambios fundamentales en la manera en que hasta ahora se toman decisiones. Es decir, se requiere reconsiderar las preguntas que guían los asesoramientos de impactos, quiénes participan en ellos y cómo se toman las decisiones. Limitar este debate a las cuestiones puramente científicas con expertos científicos reduce la participación del público y la posibilidad de que los tomadores de determinaciones reconozcan sus preocupaciones.

Algunos países han comenzado a aplicar un enfoque integral en las evaluaciones de impacto de los cultivos GM. Por ejemplo, la Ley de Tecnología Genética de Noruega establece criterios de evaluación de la sostenibilidad, beneficios sociales y aspectos éticos.

A pesar de las muchas cuestiones sin resolver, la introducción de cultivos transgénicos en la agricultura mexicana avanza rápidamente. Nos preguntamos si este ritmo de introducción de maíz GM está sobrepasando nuestra capacidad de comprender y abordar sus impactos ambientales y sociales potencialmente irreversibles ¿La agricultura y la sociedad mexicanas necesitan maíz GM? Para responder esto es importante evaluar otras alternativas más seguras y con capacidad de enfrentar los retos de producción de alimentos.

México se encuentra en un punto crítico en las decisiones sobre el maíz GM, y aún podrían evitarse sus potenciales efectos adversos. Todavía existe oportunidad para abordar las preguntas críticas sobre los riesgos del cultivo genéticamente modificado. El momento para esto es ahora. Simplemente no podemos esperar otros 10 años.

Etiquetas: , , , , ,