jueves, abril 15, 2010

CFS statement on NRC report

NRC Report on Genetically Engineered Crops Misses the Mark on “Sustainability”

Genetically Engineered Crops Are Already Having Negative Impact on Farm Sustainability in the United States

The Center for Food Safety today released a statement in response to a National Research Council (NRC) report that purports to address the impact of genetically engineered (GE) crops on “farm sustainability,” understood to include farmer economic welfare as well as the environment. Center for Food Safety Executive Director Andrew Kimbrell reacted to the report, which was released this morning by NRC in Washington, DC:


At issue is Monsanto’s Roundup Ready technology, which is found in over 70% of GE crops grown on 130 million acres in the U.S. Roundup Ready crops are engineered to survive direct application of glyphosate, the active ingredient of Roundup herbicide, which would kill or injure a conventional crop. Roundup Ready crops do not increase yield. Rather, they have provided about a decade of convenient, labor-saving weed control by facilitating vastly increased and more frequent use of glyphosate, perhaps the most effective weed-killer ever developed.

The costs of what the NRC calls ‘excessive reliance’ on Roundup Ready technology are legion. In just 14 years, the Roundup Ready system has triggered an epidemic of glyphosate-resistant weeds, in the same way that an overused antibiotic fosters resistant bacteria. Resistant weeds lead to increased pesticide use, which in turn harms the environment and human health. The leading independent study demonstrates that Roundup Ready crops and resistant weeds have increased use of herbicides (weed-killing pesticides) by 383 million lbs. over what would otherwise have been used in the 13 years from 1996 to 2008. Resistant weeds also trigger greater use of soil-eroding tillage, and in some cases manual hoeing to remove weeds, as well as higher production costs.

Significantly, glyphosate-resistant weeds are becoming so prevalent as to undermine the efficacy of glyphosate itself in ever more areas of the country. In response, companies are introducing crops resistant to non-glyphosate and multiple herbicides – an ultimately futile approach that will simply deepen the pesticide dependence of the American farmer.

In short, the biotech industry’s flagship product is proving to be inherently unsustainable, digging its own grave after just a decade and a half of use, and driving development of still other short-term fixes that will in turn rapidly become obsolescent.

Center for Food Safety is not certain what ‘sustainability’ means to the NRC. In our view, it should mean farm technologies and practices that remain effective and enhance productivity over many generations, not flash-in-the-pan innovations (like Roundup Ready technology) that drive their own obsolescence in just a decade or two.

Unfortunately, the rapid takeover of the seed supply by pesticide-biotechnology companies means that farmers have ever fewer conventional seed options. Monsanto is the world’s largest seed company, followed by DuPont (#2) and Swiss-based Syngenta (#3). Other pesticide manufacturers with a large stake in the seed industry include Dow Agrosciences, and German-based Bayer CropSciences and BASF Plant Science. It should not be surprising that these pesticide companies are developing new GE seeds for use in tandem with weed-killing pesticides they also sell.

Farmers are increasingly turning away from Monsanto’s Roundup Ready seeds to conventional seeds due to astronomical GE seed prices, resistant weeds, and the ability to legally save and replant conventional seeds. (Seed-saving, a traditional practice in the U.S. and around the world, has been made illegal with patented Roundup Ready seeds.) Demand for conventional soybean seeds has outstripped supply in at least five states, which means that some farmers who want to “go conventional” are unable to do so thanks to shortage of conventional seeds.

The declining availability of conventional seeds – due in part to atrophy of public sector breeding programs – is hopefully one topic the Department of Justice and state attorneys general will explore in their ongoing investigation of anticompetitive effects of seed industry concentration. Other issues include anti-farmer seed patents, the astronomical cost of GE seeds, and a number of anticompetitive practices used by Monsanto. Monsanto has used its seed patents to wring anywhere from $85 to $160 million from U.S. farmers for allegedly saving and replanting the company’s patented seeds.

Monsanto’s latest quarterly financial report shows a massive 19% drop in earnings, which directly reflects the farmer revolt against overpriced and increasingly ineffective Roundup Ready technology. The result would have been still worse for the company if farmers had had an adequate supply of viable conventional seed alternatives to draw on.

In the end, the NRC makes too much of short-term benefits of certain GE crops, and fails to appreciate the inherent unsustainability of the pesticide-promoting technologies being offered by the industry. In addition, there is too little concern for the many adverse impacts of seed industry concentration and seed patents on farmers’ welfare.

CFS calls for a moratorium on approvals of all new pesticide-promoting GE crops; an end to utility patents on seeds such that farmers can again save and replant seeds from their harvest; and serious antitrust remedies to break up the ongoing takeover of the seed supply by pesticide companies. The Federal government should commit significant new funds for independent, public-sector breeding programs. Without strong, decisive action of this sort, the pesticide-seed-biotechnology conglomerates will continue to saddle farmers with increasingly expensive, pesticide-promoting seeds that represent the complete opposite of sustainability.

Click here to view the footnoted version of CFS’s statement

Etiquetas: , ,

miércoles, abril 14, 2010

Study Says Overuse Threatens Gains From Modified Crops

Genetically engineered crops have provided “substantial” environmental and economic benefits to American farmers, but overuse of the technology is threatening to erode the gains, a national science advisory organization said Tuesday in a report. ARTICLE BY ANDREW POLLACK, october 13 2010. READ THE WHOLE ARTICLE AT: http://www.nytimes.com/2010/04/14/business/energy-environment/14crop.html?pagewanted=1&src=busln

Dave Kaup/Reuters

The report is described as the first comprehensive assessment of the impact of genetically modified crops on American farmers, who have rapidly adopted them since their introduction in 1996. The study was issued by the National Research Council, which is affiliated with the National Academy of Sciences and provides advice to the nation under a Congressional charter.

The report found that the crops allowed farmers to either reduce chemical spraying or to use less harmful chemicals. The crops also had lower production costs, higher output or extra convenience, benefits that generally outweighed the higher costs of the engineered seeds.

“That’s a long and impressive list of benefits these crops can provide, and have provided to adopting farmers,” David E. Ervin, the chairman of the committee that wrote the report, said on Tuesday during a webcast news conference from Washington.

But Dr. Ervin, a professor of environmental management and economics at Portland State University in Oregon, warned that farmers were jeopardizing the benefits by planting too many so-called Roundup Ready crops. These crops are genetically engineered to be impervious to the herbicide Roundup, allowing farmers to spray the chemical to kill weeds while leaving the crops unscathed.

Overuse of this seductively simple approach to weed control is starting to backfire. Use of Roundup, or its generic equivalent, glyphosate, has skyrocketed to the point that weeds are rapidly becoming resistant to the chemical. That is rendering the technology less useful, requiring farmers to start using additional herbicides, some of them more toxic than glyphosate.

“Farmer practices may be reducing the utility of some G.E. traits as pest-management tools and increasing the likelihood of a return to more environmentally damaging practices,” the report concluded. It said the problem required national attention.

More than 80 percent of the corn, soybean and cotton grown in the United States is genetically engineered. The crops tolerate Roundup, are resistant to insects, or both.

American farmers were the first to widely adopt the technology and still account for about half of all the engineered crops grown. The crops are also being widely grown in Latin America and parts of Asia but are still largely shunned in Europe.

The rapid adoption of the crops is evidence that American farmers see the technology as beneficial.

Critics of biotechnology, who say the crops may be risky to health and the environment, have issued studies saying that use of the crops has resulted in increased reliance on pesticides and has had only a minimal effect on crop yields.

The National Research Council report, more than 200 pages, was prepared by a committee of mainly academic scientists, and it relied primarily on peer-reviewed papers.

Still, the report is not likely to win over critics of the crops.

One critic, Charles Benbrook, said the conclusion that the crops help farmers might not be true in the future. That is because the report relies mostly on data from the first few years, before prices of the biotech seeds rose sharply and the glyphosate-resistant weeds proliferated.

“This is a very different future,” said Dr. Benbrook, an agricultural economist who is chief scientist at the Organic Center, which promotes organic food and farming. “The cost is going to be way higher. The environmental impacts are going to go up fairly dramatically.”

As prices of the biotech seeds have risen sharply, even some farmers are now starting to question whether they are worth it. Just last week, Monsanto, the leading agricultural biotechnology company, said it would lower the prices of its newest genetically engineered soybeans and corn seeds because farmers were not buying as many as it had expected.

The Justice Department is investigating whether Monsanto, which has patents on the Roundup Ready system, is violating antitrust laws, unduly increasing prices or hindering innovation.

The National Research Council report addresses this issue briefly without mentioning Monsanto. It says that patent licensing terms have “not adversely affected the economic welfare of farmers who adopt G.E. crops.” But it said there was some evidence that the availability of nonengineered crops “may be restricted for some farmers.”

Etiquetas: ,

From IATP- What we don't know about GE crops

—Ben Lilliston

After 15 years on the market, and constituting 80 percent of soybeans, corn and cotton grown in the U.S., we still know remarkably little about genetically engineered (GE) crops; and some of what we do know is cause for alarm. This is one of the main conclusions of a report released today by the National Research Council.

First, the headline picked up by the New York Times and others: there has been a rapid rise in weeds resistant to the herbicide glyphosate (also known as Roundup) that could rapidly undercut any environmental or economic benefits of GE crops. Glyphosate-resistant crops allow farmers to kill weeds with the herbicide without destroying their crop. To date, at least nine species of weeds in the U.S. have developed resistance to glyphosate since GE crops were introduced. The other primary type of GE crop is designed to produce Bacillus Thuringiensis (Bt), a bacteria deadly to insect pests. Thus far, two types of insects have developed resistance to Bt. The loss of effectiveness of glyphosate and Bt crops could lead to increased use of more potent herbicides.

"This problem is growing, it's real, and it's going to get worse," said chair of the NRS committee David Ervin, of Portland State University, at a press conference today.

But just as alarming as growing weed and pest resistance is the dearth of research data on so many fundamental issues surrounding GE crops. The NRC report focused on how GE crops are affecting U.S. farmers. The assessment looked at GE crops through the three pillars of sustainability: economic, environmental and social. In the end, the researchers didn't have enough data.

"As more GE traits are developed and incorporated into a larger variety of crops, it's increasingly essential that we gain a better understanding of how genetic engineering technology will affect U.S. agriculture and the environment now and in the future," said Ervin. "Such gaps in our knowledge are preventing a full assessment of the environmental, economic and other impacts of GE crops on farm sustainability."

More specifically, what we don't yet know about GE crops:

  • The full extent of weed resistance problems, or what those problems will mean in the future to the environment and farmers' bottom line.
  • Little understanding of how the use of GE crops affects water systems—positively or negatively.
  • The effects of GE crops on farmers not growing GE crops, including both conventional and organic farmers. The committee reported on anecdotal information that farmers have had trouble finding conventional non-GE seeds. And as Bob Scowcroft of the Organic Farm Research Foundation noted at the press conference, there is little peer-reviewed research on the enormous costs borne by organic farmers for testing to prove their crop is GE-free, let alone farmers who have lost organic certification from GE contamination.
  • The impact of consolidation in the seed industry—accelerated by the transition to proprietary GE seeds—on prices and seed choices.
  • Other social issues that have been overlooked include the impact of GE crops on labor dynamics, farm structure, farmer and community conflict and property rights.

The White House and USDA Secretary Tom Vilsack should take a good look at this report. After 15 years, we still can't fully assess whether GE crops are good for U.S. farmers—let alone consumers. Yet, the White House and Vilsack continue to aggressively push for other countries to use GE crops. As IATP's Dennis Keeney and Sophia Murphy wrote last month in the Des Moines Register, GE crops that are widely used in the U.S. don't make sense for the challenges facing Africa, for example.

Given the NRC report's findings, it's hard to justify the enormous amounts of money spent on the development of new GE crops, and harder still to justify pushing the technology on other countries, until we fill in the enormous research gaps that remain.

Etiquetas: ,